I was looking forward to seeing the latest remake of Emily Bronte's classic novel "Wuthering Heights". It is the story of a doomed love affair between Cathy and Heathcliff, a love that would have repercussions even after their deaths.
![]() |
| (image taken from the internet) |
Generally, I am not a big fan of remakes, but the male lead Jacob Elordi was so excellent in last year's remake of "Frankenstein" that I wanted to see him in the role of Heathcliff.
Then I started to read that critics panned the movie. However, there were others who praised it. So, on Valentine's Day, we went ahead to see it. The criticism of the movie by many was entirely justified. I thought the movie was a disaster.
Even though it has been decades since I read Bronte's novel (for a book report in the ninth grade), I could tell that the movie was not faithful to the book. First of all, the film only covers the first half of the book. Secondly, many characters have been eliminated completely... for example, Cathy's brother Hinton is mentioned but never appears. Other characters have been changed. Cathy's father, Mr. Earnshaw, is a kindly man. In the movie, he is a cruel alcoholic who nearly beats young Heathcliff to death. I was willing to accept these changes. After all, none of the film adaptations, not even the classic 1939 movie with Laurence Olivier and Merle Oberon, have been faithful to the book.
But what really turned me off, was what one reviewer called the "smutification" of the novel. In the book, aside from one kiss, the two lovers never consummate their passionate desires for each other. In the movie, Heathcliff and Cathy (now married to Mr. Linton) have sex again and again ad nauseum. There are sex scenes between two of the servants and between Heathcliff and Linton's sister that are strongly sadomasochistic. I felt like I was watching soft-porn instead of a classic of English literature.
The director, Emerald Fennell said that the movie reflects the way she felt when she first read the novel when she was 14 years old. Well, she must have been a very dirty-minded teenager!


